Hi

Not mirrored in my own personal experience.

A good CDP to these ears has more detail, a quieter noise floor, and I would say even greater dynamic range , even if it can become digitally grating (if not countered with careful CD selection, set up and CD player choice)

in terms of bass, well, if I want bass extesion to scare the neighbours I'd put an LP on not a CD. LPs to my ears have more bass slam, greater solidity in the mid-band and a natural fluidity that has something about it that is inherantly right.

CD's have finally come of age - products like the DAC 64, Wadias and the like giving more depth and solidity than ever before. At last!!!! it only took 20 years!!

Red book CD overtaking LP???? no, I think the presentation will always be different. It simply cant overtake because we are comparing apples with oranges, which I think is a key point.

SACD may have the best of both worlds, for those who fancy buying their record collection in a third format, replacing all their CDs

**NB**

Three whacks of a cane and no dinner for whoever came up with 'digitalians' and 'vinyalisa'  FFS!!

I like both formats, am I a digitlasian?