SACD vs DVD-Audio format

Hi Guys,

May all of you worry about the war of Sacd and DVD-Audio, so am I.

may be we find some answer from this web site

http://www.disctronics.co.uk/downloads/tech_docs/dvdaudio.pdf

Cheer


Han

 

The article contains nothing that most of us don't already know and it's a blatant propaganda paper in favour DVD-A dressed up as something serious

Michael.

 

Not that this report is promoting DVD-A or anything.

 

Agree.

Here is another link.

ESP link

One interesting point rised, well at least for me, is this.

quote.

I think it is a little embarrassing that no good DVD-A recordings have been released so far. They have all been of inferior quality. This has of course not made it easier for ordinary people to make a relevant opinion about the differences in the systems. The SACD recordings from Jan-Erik Persson at Opus3 are far superior everything released from DVD-A.

Now, when looking at "recordings in holistic view", the debate of the storing media/system is much less important than the skills of the recording engineer – a good recording stored on compact cassette is far superior to a bad recording stored on DVD-A. But every debate has its time and place. It is not relevant to point out more important issues when we are about to choose a new storage media.

This time the storage media (SACD versus DVD-A) is the question, and it can very easily be distorted by comparing the systems on different recordings. The better recording will always win.

The music is even more important of course, than the recording, but it is entirely subjective – not much to debate about.

 

Thank you guys.

Hi wolfgang,

Do you got any link/web site about this more deep into it.
(more technical info)

Yes, I agree with you.

thank you again
Han

quote.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Now, when looking at "recordings in holistic view", the debate of the storing media/system is much less important than the skills of the recording engineer
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

See if you can click on the underlined word above mark as

ESP link.

 

Dear wolfgang,

Yes, I do and do you got any other link/web site about this more deep into it.

(more technical info)

 

Sorry I did not get you question last time. I post the link to see if every one think this is the true reason why recordings in the new format sounds better.

No I don't have any more reference. I do not have a SACD or DVDA player yet. If I found anymore I'll post it.

 

Hi wolfgang,

That okay. Thank you again.

Cheer

Han

 

Here's the best site giving the independent pro-SACD position.