The Devil
IHTFP
Not reading the thread, #3 was the one I preferred.
#4, #2 were hot on the highs and #1 came pretty close to 3.
Scientifically, I looked at the files from a more molecular state after listening and I can assure you that each is 'different" Whether we can tell the difference or not is pure subjectivity and this is based on "opinion" or "honesty" based on the impressions at the specific time after listening (which is certainly subject to change)
The above said, some people simply cannot hear differences. Some people cannot hear differences that by others are preceived as "large" and I know one fellow who absolutely could not hear a difference of 1.5dB, even when it hit me 'upside of" my face.
Since the poll is concluded, is their a post telling "what is what?"
edit--
hehe, I saw page 5. Cool!
On a given day, I know certainly that something I prefer one day may not be preferrable the next. This is why in mastering, it is critical to go back to a 'known' reference track at least once every 30 mins. as to not dig a hole you cannot get out of with any rebalancing or voicing. The fact remains, our preception changes and cannot be an absolute.
Genuwine lol, from the heart of my bottom.