Windbag is worse threat than Terrorists..

kennyk said:
I've never been a burden on the NHS A&E dept due to alcohol. I know when to stop drinking. why tar everyone with the same brush?
Click to expand...
No-one is tarring you, Kenny. You are giving a good impression of a selfish, petulant oaf, however.
 
The Devil said:
I think that you are merely attempting to annoy, but please point out the "bullshit", giving your reasons why you think he is incorrect.

It seems obvious to me that you really don't grasp the issues. There is a massive amount of data to show that increasing the price of alcohol in a population reduces consumption. You are arguing from a (typically British) selfish perspective.
Click to expand...


the rise in gun crime since handguns was outlawed is one reason why I believe he is incorrect.

I would have thought that you would have grasped that the solution is to treat the cause rather than the symptom.

Yes, increasing price will reduce comsumption, but I put it to you again that it is not the solution to the problem

the fact that people with access to far cheaper alcohol seem to manage without the same problems seems to speak volumes.

of the 50% of your patients you claim as direct alcohol related, please give me an idea of how many brew their own.
 
I don't know how many brew their own, it's irrelevant. What's relevant is that the amount consumed needs to fall, and I'm glad that you finally concede that increasing the price will achieve that.
 
where are the mods when you need them..?

this thread's is going nowhere...may as well close it...sigh... :(
 
nope...but your post does indeed confirm where it's going... ;)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Well one mod's opinion is that Bub has a point. He is after all, as he pointed out, a liver specialist and sees the problem first hand. Which is more than can be said for most of us. As for the name calling, both parties are equally guilty IMO and whilst it does breach the guidelines, let hope it doesn't get worse. If it does, then posts will be deleted and/or thread locked.

Let's keep it friendly guys.
 
The Devil said:
People demonstrate that they can't, in fact, drink responsibly. So we have to control their drinking.
Click to expand...

This is the crux of the problem. Too many people don't know when to stop. Too much bother is caused. If affects many aspects in society.

As the Devil has pointed out, alot of hassle and cost in the health service is due to drink and drink related problems.

As I have pointed out & also PeteH, who are these irresponsible people few? One reason why it is not easy is the nature and effect of alcohol. It is a depressant. This affect the nervous system which results in slowing of responses, reaction, thinking, movement etc.

The effects vary from person to person but increase with more alcohol. This can lead, in the short term, to agressive behaviour, mood swings, violence, arguments, anxienty plus load of other things.

Anyone potentially can suffer this and people from all walks of life do.

I have seen and experienced alcohol related crime or incident. I have been a victim of it. I can tell it is not all done by so called "chavs".


SCIDB
 
The Devil said:
Drunken louts are not "fun". They harm themselves, and others. They damage the economy, and we are all (taxpayers) paying for that. This has nothing to do with snobbery nor elitism. The well-off always have a better time than the poor. It is possible to have fun without becoming completely inebriated.

You lot really have no idea about the extent of the problem. 50% of my in-patient workload is directly attributable to alcohol.
Click to expand...

I dont deny that there are a lot of people no doubt coming to you with alcohol related illnesses. Are they all young'uns though? Or are a lot of them fat, sweaty alcoholics who actually dont bother anyone else except for themselves? I suspect an equal measure, but I mainly suspect that its the young'uns who arent ill, but actually end up in A&E...

And as for louts, well, they often say drink brings out the true person inside... so if they are louts when drunk, then they would likely be louts if they had no access to, or be able to afford, drink. Maybe they'd go and mug an old granny for a £7 pint of beer...
 
I don't think so. People will always drink, but it's the amount which matters.

I have one patient at present who has been in my ward - occupying an acute medical bed - for FIVE MONTHS. The reason for his long stay is that he is homeless, and social services are trying to 'place' him into institutional care. He is by no means atypical.
 
I'd say that if you want to reduce binge drinking, then increasing the prices at late night drinking establishments would go a long way towards that.

People drink irresponsibly at home (or on the streets in some cases) sure - but I feel attacking it at a late night social/cultural level will cause greatest effect.

When I take my holidays in Europe, its always a pleasant suprise to find more people drinking coffee in late night cafes, eating meals and having a relaxed pleasant time with a bottle of wine.

Again, I think we need to attack binge drinking as a cultural societal event. I cant think of any way of doing that other than price.

how about just making drinks expensive in pubs and clubs after 6pm on Fridays/Sat/Sunday nights?
 
Alcoholism is an illness. It can not cured by putting up the prices or banging up people in prisons. If the victim can not afford to buy alcohol, he/she will turn to meths or illicit produce that can be poisonous.
 
how about just making drinks expensive in pubs and clubs after 6pm on Fridays/Sat/Sunday nights?
Click to expand...

Good idea.

BTW an acute medical bed costs the taxpayer about £500 per day in "hotel" costs alone - without factoring in nursing & medical care, nor medication. We are all paying for that.
 
I take it some of you lot were never young then.... actually you probably were.... and a lot of you probably did this yourself when you were young, but you've had your fun, so sod the rest of us eh?

I am all for harsher punishment for causing trouble, but you lot are tarring everyone who likes a friday night drink with the same brush....
 
Devil,
As the only one in this thread in the trade, how would the health service be affected by an increase in illegal drug users?

I'm not suggesting that would happen if alcohol prices went up, just interested to hear the relative impact of drink and drugs.
 
The impact of illicit drug use upon the NHS is currently minuscule compared with alcohol.

If there was an increase in their use, then that might increase, but there's no evidence to suggest that pushing up the price of alcohol would lead to any increase in illicit drugs.
 
Just like theres no evidence to suggest if they put the price up, they'll drink less. People will buy their drink from supermarkets and smuggle it into bars instead.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top